After Ohio State’s loss to Texas in the Fiesta Bowl last night, you’ll probably see articles suggesting that the Big Ten is terrible because of their 1-6 bowl record. Or the Big Ten needs to give back their automatic BCS spot because of their recent woes in the BCS games. Or the Big Ten Champion should play the MAC Champion in the Motor City Bowl. People, please stop over-reacting!
We know that people typically remember the last thing that they see. For the Big Ten, the lasting impression from the last three Bowl Seasons are two “National Championship Game” losses from Ohio State and two BCS losses this season (Penn State losing to USC in the Rose Bowl, and Ohio State losing to Texas in the Fiesta Bowl). Ohio State lost that first “National Championship Game” to Florida, although people forget that they probably should have been playing conference arch-rival Michigan instead.
In case you’ve forgotten, that season both Ohio State and Michigan were 11-0 and ranked #1 and #2 respectively, going into their season ending classic. Ohio State won that game 42-39, and the voters deemed that they were still the #1 and #2 teams in the country in the polls and in the BCS after the game. They were on a collision course for a “National Championship Game” rematch, until media groupthink came into play. The sentiment was that people didn’t want to see a rematch, or Michigan shouldn’t be in the game because they didn’t win their conference. Subsequently, Michigan was jumped by Florida when the Gators won the SEC Championship Game. Voters who changed their vote should feel ashamed. (BTW… Voters were sure to put Texas into the Title Game this season without a Big 12 Title, had Oklahoma lost to Missouri in the Big 12 Title Game). Had Michigan played in that game (and guaranteed Big Ten National Champion), would the Big Ten be looked at differently? Absolutely!
I can’t fault Penn State losing to a pro team in USC by two touchdowns. Nor can I fault Ohio State’s three point lost to Texas with 16 seconds left. Ohio State definitely had opportunities to “seal the deal” during the Longhorn’s last drive if they didn’t commit the personal foul penalty, or if they made the stop on the 4th down attempt. They lost to a great Texas team, who had public sentiment to play in this year’s “National Championship Game” instead of Oklahoma.
As far as the other Big Ten Bowl Teams, in the conference’s only victory Iowa dominated South Carolina. If Michigan State put touchdowns on the board in the 1st half against pre-season #1 Georgia instead of field goals, Michigan State should have won. Northwestern should have beaten Missouri, in its overtime loss. Wisconsin and Minnesota were both overmatched in their bowl games.
Match-ups are the reason the Big Ten didn’t do as well this year. All told, out of the 6 Big Ten losses in bowl games, three teams were ranked #1 at one point during the season (Georgia, USC, and Texas), one team was ranked as high as #2 (Missouri), and two teams were ranked as high as #15 (Kansas and Florida State). Although you never like to lose, they didn’t lose to slouches either.
The Big Ten isn’t that far away from being considered an “elite” conference. Ohio State will contend for National Championships the next 2-3 years with Terrelle Pryor leading them. Penn State will be competitive on the national scene. Michigan State is a team to look for in the future (as early as 2009, but definitely 2010), due to Mark Dantonio’s coaching and the good recruiting classes he is accumulating. Any of these three teams can and will win BCS games or the BCS Title.
Besides, the conference with the best overall record is the Pac-10 with a 5-0 record. Does anybody think any team other than USC is any good? USC’s only loss was to Oregon State, who was dominated by Penn State and lost to Utah. Oregon State won its bowl game against Pitt by the score of 3-0. That is not a typo. 3-0.
Talk to me in two years, and let’s see if we’ll be having this discussion. We probably will, but it won’t be in reference to the Big Ten.
DC is a contributor to The Sports Information Hub and can be contacted at dcthesportsguy@gmail.com